In the first two reading passages (excluding the Robinson article), we are presented with two very different methods of theological thought. Whereas Thomas Aquinas primarily discusses theological issues in a manner that is structured and to the point, Anselm's writing, the Proslogium, is more characterized by an internal "discourse" that delves into personal theological struggles. For most of us, Aquinas' method is closer to what we are used to, as it is more academically oriented. Therefore, it is important to examine more closely the Proslogium, as though it might be more foreign to us, it nevertheless contains great insight. So, how does Anselm's method of writing and "doing" theology impact the content and issues with which he is dealing? In other words, how does his style affect the reader's understanding of what he is trying to communicate.
Then in regards to Aquinas, in Article 1, the first objection brings up philosophical science and how "we have no need of any further knowledge." Aquinas, later on, refutes this point and disproves it. Yet, this point brings a different question: what is the relationship of philosophy and theology? Last semester, a similar question arose in our reading of "The Philosophical Act" by Josef Pieper. Pieper maintains that theology and philosophy seek answers to the same questions, but have different approaches. If this is the case, then which method of seeking answers do you feel is more effective?
Both Aquinas and Anselm hold that faith is the starting point of theology, which then leads to reason and hopefully to understanding. Anselm states this almost directly and Aquinas says that divine revelation is necessary to know certain truths, thereby implying it. Since faith is a gift, not a product of man's own work, how is it that some people are apparently born with faith, while others it can take years to find, and still others may never gain it. How does this fit in with the Christian understanding of God's love and His desire for all His creation to seek Him and find Him?
Dan Grabowski, Andrew Krema, Rhodes Bolster
